Digital In Black And White Ink Jet Printing Problems And Solutions

Digital Piezography Black & White Printing
Inkjet Problems and Solutions
David B. Brooks, December, 2001

Is 01 02 03 04 Test Print Arthur

The most effective and efficient method I have used to add a controlled amount of color to an image converted from Grayscale to RGB mode is to use the Fill command with the Color (only) mode selected once the color is selected. I also found that selecting a dark hue of the desired tone to make a warm black was most effective, which from my experience is an orange. Then if in Adobe Photoshop or a similar Color Picker, a value is selected from the color gamut corresponding to a dark shadow at a low intensity or saturation initially, that color will come closest to resulting in a printed warm black.
Photos © 2001, David B. Brooks, All Rights Reserved

The output device for most digital darkrooms has become the photo-realistic ink jet printer. The printers that are designed to produce high quality photographic image reproduction are primarily color printers. They can be used for a wider range of applications, including printing text in pure black and white, and provide a good quality result. However, if used to print a black and white (gray scale in computer terms) image when the printer driver is set on black ink only (gray scale), the range of print densities produced is usually not comparable to that produced when a color photograph is made with the printer. The reason is that ink jet printers are CMYK type printers, and, in the case of most photo-realistic models, use six instead of the four standard colors of garden-variety ink jets.

A black ink only print from a gray scale image file is then limited to just the number of ink drops which can be applied from the black ink, approximately by 1/6 of those available to make a full color print. The result is a print that lacks the tonal range, smoothness, and depth of tones of a color image made with the same printer. However, as printer resolution has increased, combined with the use of smaller jet sizes (now down to four pico liters) the number of jets in a print head for each color including black has been increased. This new advantage, of course, functions only when the printer’s top resolution setting is selected. And, in the case of the latest 2880dpi Epson printers, this highest setting can only be used when printing Glossy or Premium Glossy photo paper. This will satisfy many practical needs for black and white photographic prints. But for the photographer who has done fine black and white printing in a traditional darkroom, as well as anyone who wants to emulate the photographic tradition of fine black and white prints exemplified by the likes of Ansel Adams, and who has used high quality fine arts printing papers, there is no ready, automatic, click and print black and white solution.

ONE Using Color Inks To Make B&W Ink Jet Prints

Simple logic suggests that if printing with just the black ink alone does not produce the same image qualities as are produced in color image printing, why not use all of the ink colors to print a gray scale image file to make a black and white print? Most printer drivers support this by just setting the print command to color when printing a gray scale image. Unfortunately, even though the printer driver sends commands to the printer to lay down equal amounts of each color of ink to produce a range of neutral grays, there is enough variation in these mass produced machines that the amounts of each color of ink are not "exactly" applied to the paper. The result is not an entirely neutral range of gray tones in the print but a tint of either magenta or cyan, neither of which is a very attractive tone for a fine black and white print.

Not-So-Neutral Silver Prints

This off-color black and white printing result, reproducing a gray scale image using all ink colors, can be overcome, although it is almost impossible to obtain a perfectly neutral print tone. That should not be the goal anyway, if you pay attention to the fact that silver-based black and white prints usually have a subtle tint of color and are seldom a dead-neutral black. The reason is, first, that most modern silver-based printing paper emulsions combine both silver bromide and silver chloride salts for the best combination of print speed and image tone characteristics. There have been some photo papers that are dead neutral, such as Kodak Kodabromide and Agfa Brovira, but most contemporary black and white papers tend to have at least a little of the warm black created by some amount of silver chloride content in the emulsion. In addition, most fine photographic printers also apply a mild selenium or gold tone solution to their prints to enhance their archival life, which would shift the image color subtly.

To achieve a similar result using an ink jet printer applying all of the printer’s ink colors demands some individual trial and error testing to modify the image file being printed. The goal is to create a tone that is a bit off dead-center gray. To do this in a digital darkroom first requires that the 8-bit gray scale image mode is changed to 24-bit RGB mode. With a black and white image in RGB each of the three color channels have the same values, for instance a dark tone might be R-42, G-42, B-42. To get the printer off dead center the values need to be not all the same, maybe R-41, G-42, B-43. The combination of RGB values that will work to provide a pleasing and satisfactory result is where the trial and error testing comes into play.

Creating a "test" print image which contains a variety of subtle color variations side by side supports the easiest and most accurate means to make a visual selection of specific RGB number value colors to use to achieve a pleasant and reasonably neutral black and white image tone using all of the ink colors for printing gray scale image files.

Although black and white images printed with the Epson 2000P using all of the ink colors will provide color stability over a long life, metamerism must be taken into consideration if the illumination of displayed prints change or cannot be predicted. If the display illumination is known and will remain constant, added coloration to achieve a very neutral gray/black is possible. Otherwise it is better to select a saturated monochrome tone which simulates a brown or sepia toned traditional black and white print.

Bias Shifts

Logic would also suggest that the colors to make test prints would be the complement of the printer’s color shifts. For instance, if the shift produces a print with a magenta tone rather than neutral gray, then this would presumably be corrected (balanced) by adding green. However, from my experience performing the tests, the results suggest that as soon as the RGB values are moved off dead center (equal amounts of R, G, and B values) the printer accurately reproduces the color information it is given. In other words, if the gray scale print shift is magenta, then adding a bit of green does not result in a neutral gray tone, but a greenish tone. Based on this result my strategy changed in selecting colors to test to obtain a pleasant (to me) warm black print tone using all the colors of the printer.

The test image file then should contain several selections of color applied to an image area that contains all of the tone brightness values from black to white. I made my test print image by opening a new image that is 8x10" by 300dpi resolution. I also made another new image 1x6" by 300dpi. In this smaller image I used the Graduated Fill tool to apply a graduated tone from white at the top to black at the bottom. I then copied this gray scale image and pasted six copies of it in the 8x10 image. (I also pasted a copy of a scanned IT-8 reference image at the top of the page as a visual reference.)

I then used the rectangle selection tool to select each of the five individual gray scale bars on the right, leaving the one on the left neutral gray. As each was selected I applied a different color using the Fill Layer command detailed in illustration above. My first version of this test image was then printed. (This test should be printed once on each different paper that you might want to use for reproducing black and white images in the future.) On the basis of the result, it was revealed that each color addition was too strong, so I again used the rectangle selection tool applied to each bar and used the Hue&Saturation tool to shift the color value (Hue) as well as reduce the Saturation from 50 percent to as much as 75 percent. I then made another set of test prints. From this I was able to select a color to add to black and white images that would print a desirable warm black tone to my eyes.

Once you have settled on a choice of color, make a note of the RGB values, and also if you have reduced saturation. Then choose a couple of black and white images with differing kinds of subjects and tonal distribution to make final, practical test prints. The procedure using Photoshop 6.0 or Elements, as well as a similar procedure with most image editors like PhotoPaint or Picture Window, is similar.

First, use the Image/Mode menu to change the image from gray scale to RGB. Then select the Layer menu command Fill Layer and select color. Designate the Mode as Color (only), and when the Color Picker window is open type in the RGB number values for the color selection you have made. If you need to reduce the saturation, you will have to go to the Layer menu and select Merge Visible, and then open the Hue/Saturation dialog from the Image/Adjust menu selection. Apply the Saturation reduction. Now you are ready to print.

The Lyson Quad Black ink set (neutral) produces prints with a warm black range of tones producing black and white prints with attributes very comparable to fine, traditional prints made in a darkroom. This high level of performance however, is dependent on selecting a printing paper that is compatible with the Lyson inks assuring a full range of tones and the print brilliance the image deserves.

Using The Epson 2000P

The method mentioned, when customized to the paper and a particular printer, will work effectively with all of the Epson Stylus Photo series of printers that use dye-based inks, excepting the 2000P. Although there are basic similarities between the Epson Stylus Photo 2000P and the other Photo series dye ink Epson printer models, with the same problems of a color shift when printing black and white with all of the ink colors, there are differences which affect a solution. The test process to find a color to achieve a pleasant image tone is the same. Even so, the characteristics of the Epson 2000P pigment inks present another challenge.

Pigment-based inks used with ink jet printers, unlike dye inks which soak into the printing material, tend to remain more on the surface and do not infuse into the paper material because pigments are solids while dyes are liquids. This makes the pigment ink on the surface of the print capable of reflecting some of the light illuminating the print. If the print illumination color characteristics change, as they do between daylight coming in a window and tungsten room lighting, the appearance of the print tone will shift color. This is a thoroughly researched and well documented phenomenon called metamerism. And, when the print is a monochrome, a black and white image, it is even more apparent in the print when illumination is changed.

Because of this quite apparent effect of metamerism, Epson’s recommendation is to make black and white prints with the 2000P which have more color, like a sepia-toned print. Of course, the other alternative is to make a more neutral colored black and white print if you are assured the print will always be illuminated by just one source of light, like a specific kind of indoor lighting. And it should be obvious that the illumination in your workroom should match the illumination where the print will be displayed, so the color you choose will be the tone of the print when viewed. To test this I printed three images, one with a very subtle color addition that produced a print very close to neutral warm black, another with a mild, warmer tone like that of a silver print processed with an archival amount of gold toner, and the last a richly colored sepia-toned print.

Prints made with the Cone Editions Piezography BW inks and software, even on moderate cost ink jet matte photo paper, exhibit a full range of tones with excellent shadow and highlight detail. The Piezography BW system used with the Epson 1160 printer and its small ink droplet size produces the finest definition of detail and image sharpness that can be made in a black and white print with a modest cost 13" wide ink jet printer.

These three images were printed on both the Epson SemiGloss paper for the 2000P as well as a new finely textured matte fine arts paper called Schoellershammer Velvet, obtained from Digital Art Supplies (http://www.digitalartsupplies.com). The color tones were selected and the prints were made in a room lit with tungsten. When the prints were moved into a room illuminated by indirect window light varying amounts of metamerism was apparent. Both of the "sepia" prints appeared now to be a cool brown, the print on the semigloss more so. Both of the "gold tone" prints took on a yellowish green cast, which was more pronounced in the semigloss print. The neutral prints took on a cooler tint that was decidedly cyan in the semigloss print. It was apparent that the semigloss paper holds more of the 2000P ink on the surface and is more subject to the effect of metamerism, and the finely textured matte Schoellershammer Velvet paper was less so. The test also revealed that a deeply colored "sepia" print tone reduces the apparent metamerism effect, or at least the shift is not as unpleasant.

TWO Independent Brand All Black Ink Sets

For the serious black and white photographer the most obvious solution to obtaining full tone range photographic prints with a color ink jet printer would be to replace the color inks with black ink. Ink manufacturers independent of the printer companies agree with this concept and offer ink sets for a number of printers, including many of the Epson models as well as some of the Canon BubbleJet printers. And, although Epson does not officially support the use of third-party inks, they were kind enough to loan me the use of an Epson Stylus Photo 1200 printer so I could do some testing. Independent all-black ink cartridges are not available for my 1270 and the new 1280 printer, as well as the letter-size models that correspond with these latest Stylus Photo models. Of the suppliers of all-black inks I chose just one to test, Lyson Inc., which was the first to come to my attention several years ago with their Quad Black ink sets (www.lysonusa.com).

I used the term "serious" because the use of all-black ink sets involves thoroughly cleaning the print head with special "cleaning" cartridges before the new black inks are used, which involves some expense and time. So, it is really only practical, convenient, and economical if you dedicate a printer to black ink only use. In other words, switching a printer back and forth between color inks and all-black inks is not a satisfactory solution. The cleaning process has very stringent demands. You must thoroughly remove any trace of the old ink from the print head. From the information I have, and one sad personal experience ruining a printer, any mixing of one type of ink with another raises the possibility of coagulation that could result in permanent clogging of the print head jets. The all-black inks include a standard full strength black and the color cartridge replacement includes varying dilutions of black (grays). This assures the standard printer driver set on color will apply ink densities that will result in an appropriate range of tones in the final print. The Lyson Quad Black inks are dye based and also provide what is considered archival print life under normal display conditions (test results are available at www.wilhelm-research.com). And, Lyson offers three selections of print tone color choice--Cool, Neutral, and Warm. For my tests I had to limit my use to the Neutral version of the Quad Black inks.

I began my testing with my standard paper that I chose for its very bright neutral white and excellent performance printing color with the Epson 1270/1280 printer, which is Hahnemuhle Photo Matte, a moderate cost paper for ink jets I purchased from Digital Art Supplies. These first test prints were disappointing in their muted, muddy contrast, completely lacking any depth in the blacks. Before coming to any conclusion I decided to print on some other papers I had in stock, including the relatively expensive Concorde Rag (as well as some other sample papers) and the new Schoellershammer Velvet I mentioned earlier. From these additional print tests the more expensive fine arts papers, particularly the Concorde Rag and Schoellershammer Velvet, reproduced very high quality full tonal-range prints. This led me to think that papers with very hard surfaces and less absorbent coatings are most effective with the Lyson Quad Black inks.

By printing a variety of black and white image subjects, I found that once I selected a color which resulted in a pleasant print tone, I could reduce the saturation of the color fill after merging the Fill Layer with the Background between 50 and 75 percent. This increased the neutrality of light and middle grays resulting in a more traditional appearing print produced with the Epson 1270/1280 printers using a matte, fine arts paper.

THREE Piezography BW By Cone Editions Press

For the really serious black and white digital photographer, Cone Editions press offers Piezography BW, a complete software and materials solution designed for select Epson printers to produce archival pigment ink black and white prints of the highest quality. The Cone Editions Piezography BW kits include the necessary ink sets, cleaning cartridges, and software to produce prints using ICQ profiles for a wide range of popular fine art and photo ink jet papers. The software is an Adobe Photoshop Export plug-in which takes over control of some of the key functions of the Epson print driver and allows tight, repeatable quality control of the output, including adjustment of both image gamma and ink dot density to control print mid-tone lightness/ darkness and the amount of ink applied. Currently Piezography kits are available to provide black and white fine art quality printing with the Epson 760, 800, 850, 860, 1160, 1200, 1520, and 3000 printers. The cost of the initial kits range from $335 for most of the consumer line of Epson printers to $550 for the professional 3000 model. Additional ink sets (both grays and black) are $80 a pair for all of the consumer Epson printers.

Cone Editions founder Jon Cone provided a kit for me to test, but I had to acquire a compatible Epson printer on my own. Having a substantial interest in black and white printing, being an "old-timer" with 75-80 percent of my archives black and white negatives, I decided this was as good a time as any to equip myself with an appropriate printer. Colleagues as well as the staff at Cone Editions suggested an Epson Stylus Color 1160 as the best affordable choice in a 13" wide printer. The reasons given were that a four-color printer is better adapted to all-black ink printing, and the 1160 model, among 13" wide printers, uses the latest Epson technology utilizing a four picoliter ink droplet size which will achieve the sharpest detail and smoothest tone gradations. The very week I made the decision to buy this printer, Epson discontinued it. However, I was able to buy the last one in stock at my local office supply store. If anyone else is interested, refurbished units of the 1160 model are available from The Epson Store as well as other select outlets.

Getting started with the Epson 1160 was the same as if I were going to use it for color printing with Epson inks, installing the hardware and software following the Epson guide. Then after making a couple of test prints to confirm it functioned properly, I removed the ink cartridges and replaced them with the cleaning cartridges from the Piezography kit and performed a thorough flushing of the print head. I then installed the Piezography software Photoshop plug-in and the Piezography BW ink cartridges.

I then printed a number of images from the selection of about 40 fresh scans of medium and large format negatives, from which I selected all the images for test printing for this article. A package of letter-size papers stocked and sold by the Cone Editions web outlet, www.inkjetmall. com was used, as well as the Hahnemuhle Photo Matte I have come to value, and Concorde Rag included with the Cone Editions samples, plus the new Schoellershammer Velvet. The Schoellershammer Velvet and Hahnemuhle Photo Matte do not have ICQ profiles provided with the Piezography BW software, but by selecting a couple of "standard" profiles for papers with similar attributes and then making minor adjustments to the gamma and dot density sliders, I was able to obtain very comparable quality results to the profiled papers I test printed.

My first impression from these print results is that the Piezography BW printing solution is very adept at handling both all kinds of image characteristics as well as a wide range of papers from moderate cost photo ink jet papers to premium fine arts papers. I was particularly pleased with the results obtained with the new Schoellershammer Velvet. It provided equal, if not better overall print image appearance compared to my previous favorite but pricier Concorde Rag, which I found sometimes limiting because it is a very warm-toned paper.

B&W Digital Printing Conclusions And Recommendations

Black and white printing for the digital photographer is both possible and practical. It can yield image qualities at least comparable to traditional expectations. In some instances, contemporary consumer ink jet printers offer an even greater potential than traditional, plus deliver it with convenience and reasonable cost of both hardware and materials. Choosing the best option demands making a realistic assessment of need and determining how much black and white printing you would actually do. If it is only an occasional need and does not demand archival print life, existing consumer color ink jet printers, even including the more business oriented four-color printers, may be used. Once a small investment in time and a little paper and ink for tests is made, quite good quality black and white prints can be produced reliably on demand.

As with color images made with all dye-based ink jet printers, monochrome prints are subject to color shifts caused by differential ink fading if accepted display conditions and preparations are not observed. For those photographers who have or are considering the archival Epson Stylus Photo 2000P, the same approach produces either warm neutral or sepia tone prints of black and white images with excellent quality, given that the shifts in different lighting conditions are anticipated.

My conclusion is that a major involvement in black and white imaging is best served by a printer that is dedicated to black and white only. This is quite cost effective and yields a more efficient workflow, assuring a more consistent and controllable level of print image quality. Whether to simply convert an older color printer like the Epson Stylus Photo 1200 to the use of all-black inks or to acquire a four-color printer, as I did, and invest in Piezography, I think will depend on your commitment and concern about your work. It will also give you the ability to use a greater selection of printing papers. With 3/4 of my image collection black and white, and a history of interest in quality black and white printing, the decision to favor Piezography BW is an easy one for me.

Piezography BW Update:

After using the Epson Stylus Color 1160 and the Cone Editions Piezography BW software and inks for several weeks and quite a few more prints after finishing my report, the result of that additional experience needs to be related. Although the prints produced continued to be very rewarding and were even improving in quality as I gained experience, not using the system regularly combined with changing the ink cartridges apparently introduced some air bubbles into the 1160’s print head. This caused the clogging of some of the jets. After obtaining more information on print head nozzle clogging from the Cone Editions web site I attempted to clear the problem, but with no luck. I then got a new set of cleaning cartridges, and finally restored the performance of the Epson Stylus Color 1160.

The one solution that was offered by the very supportive staff at Cone Editions was to add the continuous flow bulk ink supply kit to my printer, which eliminates introducing any air into the print head when cartridges are changed, the probable cause of the clogging. This kit would be another $150 for the hardware, plus even more for an initial ink supply. However, the per-print ink cost would be reduced over using cartridges, which are expensive and don’t produce many prints. So, my original recommendation that the Cone Editions Piezography BW is a choice only serious black and white printers should make is now even more qualified, as I would not recommend planning to use the system based on any method except using a continuous flow bulk ink supply. The ink cartridges do not assure reliable performance, and are not cost effective.